Skip to content
AGENCY310Schedule a call

The Law Firm Leak Index 2026: Where Cases Are Lost Between the Search and the Signed Retainer

By Agency 310, with GrowthAgents AI

By Josh Corbelli, Founder and President

A prospect who needs a lawyer can fail to reach your firm in two ways. They may never see you, or they may see you, reach out, and wait too long for an answer. Published research covers each problem on its own. This report sets the figures next to each other for law firms.

Five numbers

  • 40% of 500 law firms picked up when Clio’s secret shoppers called in mid-2024. Counting call-backs, 52% responded.
  • 13 minutes was the median time to reply to a web form across 1,333 firms in Hennessey Digital’s Q1 2025 study. 26% had no reply after seven days.
  • 25% of firms replied in under five minutes and 56% within an hour.
  • 8% of Google visits ended in a result click when an AI summary appeared, against 15% when none did (Pew Research Center, 900 adults, 68,879 searches). Only 1% clicked a link inside the summary.
  • 50.1% of 1,110 consumers said they would use an AI tool when researching a lawyer. That is stated intent, and 71.9% said they would still use Google.

How the figures were gathered

Each study measured something different, in a different year, with a different sample. Read the numbers as separate snapshots and do not subtract one from another. The last column notes where a publisher has a stake in the topic.

StudySampleMethodDatesLimits
Clio 2024 Legal Trends500 firmsSecret shopper calls and emails, run by LuxJun 20 to Jul 5 2024Clio sells practice-management software
Hennessey Digital 20251,333 firmsWeb forms submitted under fictitious aliases, 10am to noon local timeQ1 2025Publisher is a legal marketing agency
Pew Research Center900 adults, 68,879 searchesObserved Google searchesMarch 2025Not legal-specific
iLawyerMarketing 20261,110 consumersSurvey of what people would use2026, panel and field dates not statedStated intent, not behavior
Previsible AI Traffic Report166 GA4 propertiesAnalytics data across industriesNov 2024 to May 2026, published Jul 2026No legal-specific figure
Clio 2025 Legal TrendsClio usersSelf-reported2025Correlation, not cause

The reach gap

The phone is where firms lose people first. In Clio’s secret shopper, 40% of firms answered and 52% either answered or called back, so 48% did neither. Only 33% answered an email.

Web forms look better but still leak. Hennessey submitted forms between 10am and noon local time, so these figures describe business hours. They say nothing about after-hours performance.

MeasureResultSource
Answered the phone40%Clio 2024
Answered or called back52%Clio 2024
Answered email33%Clio 2024
Median reply time to a web form13 minutesHennessey 2025
Replied in under 5 minutes25%Hennessey 2025
Replied within 1 hour56%Hennessey 2025
No reply within 7 days26%Hennessey 2025

The find gap

Google is still the default. In iLawyerMarketing’s survey, 71.9% of consumers said they would use it to research a lawyer, down from 86.7% the year before. ChatGPT rose from 28.1% to 41.9%. Half (50.1%) said they would use some AI tool and 9.5% said they would use AI only. Among ages 45 to 60, 57% said they would use ChatGPT. Treat all of this as directional, because the question asked what people would use and not what they did.

Behavior data is thinner. Pew’s observed searches show people click less when an AI summary appears. Previsible found LLM referral sessions grew 9.9 times between November 2024 and May 2026, with ChatGPT supplying 92.4% of trackable LLM referrals. That data spans industries and has no legal-specific figure, so it cannot tell you how much of your own traffic comes from AI.

MeasureResultSource
Result click when an AI summary appeared8%Pew 2025
Result click when no AI summary appeared15%Pew 2025
Click on a link inside the AI summary1%Pew 2025
Searches that showed an AI summary18%Pew 2025
Would use ChatGPT to research a lawyer41.9% (28.1% in 2025)iLawyerMarketing 2026
Would use Google71.9% (86.7% in 2025)iLawyerMarketing 2026
Would use any AI tool50.1%iLawyerMarketing 2026
Would use AI only9.5%iLawyerMarketing 2026
Growth in LLM referral sessions, Nov 2024 to May 20269.9 times, all industriesPrevisible 2026

Conversion claims conflict. Seer Interactive found ChatGPT referrals converted at 15.9% against 1.76% for Google organic, but that came from one unnamed client’s site between October 2024 and April 2025. A separate 973-site ecommerce study found ChatGPT supplied about 0.2% of sessions and converted worse. Neither covers law firms.

On where AI engines look, 5W’s Legal AI Visibility Report tracked 25 names across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews. It found that directories and rankings supplied 30.5% of citations. Martindale-Hubbell, Avvo and Super Lawyers were named most often in answers, though the report says it cannot statistically separate them from state bar associations. The page was published June 28, 2026 and updated October 30, 2026.

What converts better at small firms

Clio’s 2025 report found firms with wide AI adoption were nearly three times as likely to report revenue growth. Its solo and small firm release lists these conversion lifts:

PracticeReported conversion liftSource
E-signatures10%Clio 2025
Text messaging7%Clio 2025
Online intake formsUp to 5%Clio 2025

These are correlations from Clio’s own users, self-reported. Firms that adopt tools may already be growing.

Score your own firm

Pull your last 90 days of leads and fill in the right-hand column. Compare the pattern, because the published figures come from different samples than yours.

Your metricPublished benchmarkYour number
Phone answered live40%
Median time to first reply to a web form13 minutes
Replies in under 5 minutes25%
No reply within 7 days26%

Revenue-at-risk model (a model, not data): monthly leads x share left unanswered x sign rate x average fee = monthly fees at risk.

Hypothetical example: 40 leads a month, 26% unanswered (the Hennessey share with no reply in seven days), a 20% sign rate and a $5,000 average fee. That is 40 x 0.26 x 0.20 x $5,000 = $10,400 a month. The sign rate and fee are invented for the example. Use your own.

Common questions

How often do law firms answer the phone?

In Clio’s 2024 secret shopper of 500 firms, 40% answered the phone and 52% either answered or called back.

How fast do law firms reply to web forms?

Hennessey Digital’s Q1 2025 study of 1,333 firms found a median reply time of 13 minutes. 25% replied in under 5 minutes, 56% within an hour, and 26% did not reply within 7 days.

Do AI summaries reduce clicks to websites?

Pew Research Center found users clicked a result on 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared and 15% when it did not. Only 1% clicked a link inside the summary.

What share of people would use AI to find a lawyer?

50.1% of 1,110 consumers surveyed by iLawyerMarketing in 2026 said they would use an AI tool. The survey measures stated intent, not behavior, and 71.9% still said they would use Google.

Disclosure

GrowthAgents AI and Agency 310 build AI intake and AI search visibility work for law firms, so we have a stake in this topic. The table near the top lists the limits of each source.

Get your firm’s Leak Score

A SiteScan readiness scan and a five-minute intake test show where your firm sits against the numbers above.

Sources

AGENCYYOUR AGENCY OF RECORD

Start with a call.

Tell us about your firm. We will tell you plainly what we would do and what it would cost.

Schedule a call